PEO vs. EOR: Which HR Solution Fits Your Business in 2025?

July 9, 2025

Hiring across state lines or expanding into new global markets is exciting—until your feet are knee-deep in payroll issues, benefits forms, and unfamiliar labor laws. HR complexity grows rapidly with growing businesses. That’s when you begin hearing about
PEO (Professional Employer Organization)
and EOR (Employer of Record), and the distinctions aren’t necessarily clear on first glance.

In reality, selecting the correct model can have a direct bearing on how well your company scales. SHRM reports that
62% of companies that grow without adequate HR support will find themselves in
compliance penalties within the first year.
Add to that the fact that
17% of U.S. companies
with 10–99 employees now use a PEO, while EOR services are catching up fast with teams employing overseas, and the choice begins to appear a lot more imperative.

If you’re wondering which one suits your purpose, you’re at the right place. This guide demystifies what a PEO and an EOR actually do, where they work best, and how to choose the one that won’t just serve your compliance purposes but also allow you to keep your focus on growing your business.

1. What Is a PEO?

A Professional Employer Organization, or PEO, becomes your
business’s co-employer.
You still control your employees’ day-to-day tasks, hiring, firing, and performance management, while the PEO assumes much of the employer burden. Those usually involve:

  • Payroll administration and tax filings under the PEO’s federal employer identification number
  • Employee benefits management, from health insurance to retirement plans
  • Workers’ compensation insurance and claims handling
  • HR compliance support covering federal, state, and local labor regulations

By aggregating clients’ employees together, PEOs bargain for group‑level rates on benefits that independent small firms typically can’t otherwise access. In 2024, PEO clients saved an average of
15% on health insurance premiums
relative to independent coverage. The PEO model is particularly appealing because it’s ideal for firms of 5 to 150 workers who want a strong HR infrastructure without creating it in‑house.

2. What Is an EOR?

An Employer of Record, or EOR, directly hires your employees on its own payroll. In a legal sense, the EOR is the employer of record in that it holds all the employment-related liabilities. Your company maintains operational control—assigning tasks, and assessing performance—but the EOR manages:

  • Employment contracts compliant with local labor laws
  • Payroll processing and tax withholdings under the EOR’s local entity
  • Mandatory benefits administration and statutory contributions
  • Full compliance responsibility for labor, immigration, and tax regulations

EORs have exploded in significance as U.S. businesses grow internationally. During 2023, the EOR industry expanded by 28% globally, fueled by remote work and borderless employment. Contrary to PEOs, EORs don’t demand that you establish a legal entity in a foreign marketplace, positioning them perfectly for firms desiring to hire internationally promptly and compliantly.

3. Four Key Differences Between PEO and EOR

3.1 Employment Relationship

  • PEO: Both you and the PEO are employer-responsible. You handle day-to-day operations while the PEO co-employs your employees for HR and compliance work.
  • EOR: The EOR is the only legal employer. Your business guides work, but the EOR has complete legal liability for payroll, benefits, and statutory compliance.

3.2 Liability and Risk

  • PEO: Liability is shared. If there is a compliance problem, both you and the PEO can share risk, although PEOs generally maintain errors-and-omissions coverage.
  • EOR: Liability falls nearly exclusively on the EOR. Since the EOR is the employer of record, it bears employment‑related risks such as misclassification, payroll miscalculations, and benefits issues.

3.3 Scope of Services

  • PEO: Provides a comprehensive set of HR services—payroll, benefits, workers’ compensation, HR consulting, and recruiting support. It’s an in‑house HR department for domestic operations.
  • EOR: Specializes in hiring, payroll, tax compliance, and benefits in one jurisdiction. Its offerings are narrower but also deeper in regulatory and legal knowledge, particularly with cross-border employment.

3.4 Ideal Business Profile

  • PEO: Best suited for small and mid-sized businesses operating mostly in the United States. Most PEOs have a minimum of five employees and top out at about 200.
  • EOR: Ideal for organizations of any size that must bring on new talent in additional states or nations without establishing local operations. There’s usually no minimum employee count, so it is amenable to rapid-expansion environments.

4. Why Market Statistics Matter in 2025

  • PEO Adoption: In the United States,
    PEOs now partner with more than 208,000 businesses,
    protecting over 3.9 million worksite employees. Those customers grow 7 to 9 percent more rapidly and experience 10 to 14 percent reduced turnover than similar businesses without PEO.
  • EOR Growth: Worldwide, EOR usage increased 28 percent in 2023. Tech, life sciences, and professional services industries are driving the trend, bringing in remote talent from 50+ countries.
  • Cost Considerations: PEO fee structures typically range from 3 to 12 percent of gross payroll. EOR fees typically range $200 to $500 per employee monthly, depending on country complexity.
  • Compliance Landscape: Since 2021, over 60 new pay transparency and gig‑worker laws have rolled out globally. EORs invest heavily in local legal teams to track these changes in real time.

5. How to Decide: PEO or EOR?

5.1 You Need a PEO If…

  • You have a domestic growth trajectory, adding headcount within the United States.
  • You want a turnkey HR department: benefits, payroll, workers’ comp, and compliance are all bundled.
  • You prefer shared liability and co‑employment so you’re not fully on the hook alone.

5.2 You Need an EOR If…

  • You are hiring in new states or countries without a legal entity.
  • You want full legal employment responsibility transferred to a provider.
  • Your priority is rapid, compliant global expansion with minimal setup time.

5.3 Walk Through Your Pain Points

  • Are you stumbling over multi‑state payroll filings or international tax codes?
  • Do you want Fortune 500‑level benefits without the group size?
  • Is your in‑house HR team stretched thin by new labor laws?

Answering these questions helps pinpoint whether a PEO vs. EOR solution best fits your roadmap.

6. Bringing a Provider Onboard

  1. Identify Your Needs: Record your HR issues—benefits management, accurate pay, compliance shortcomings, or hiring internationally.
  2. Request Detailed Proposals: Request both PEO and EOR applicants for service models, costs, liabilities, and case studies.
  3. Review Technology Platforms: Ensure that their systems are compatible with your current HRIS or payroll systems.
  4. Assess Local Expertise: For EORs, ensure they have in-country staff in each jurisdiction where you’ll be hiring. With PEOs, ensure their state-by-state compliance.
  5. Plan a 60‑Day Rollout: Map data migration, employee notices, and training so you roll into your next payroll cycle smoothly.

7. Conclusion

Selecting PEO vs. EOR is more about selecting what is best for where your business is and where it’s going. If you’re employing a U.S.-based workforce and are bogged down with HR admin, a PEO will introduce order and cost savings without significant disruption. Alternatively, if you’re expanding into new markets or recruiting internationally with no local footprint, an EOR enables you to go faster and remain compliant.

The key is clarity. A small healthcare practice in Connecticut and a European-wide hiring tech startup will require different types of assistance. So step back first and assess your HR pain points—are they compliance, benefits, multi-state regulations, or international recruiting issues? That’s usually the best indicator of which model will be the most valuable.

Still weighing your options? That’s where we can help.
OEM America assists companies
in analyzing both PEO and EOR options based on size, objectives, and future strategy. We assist you in identifying the configuration that really works.
Contact us for a customized consultation
and get the insight you need to grow assuredly and compliantly in 2025.

Go Back